On Oct. 15, Boldin, the retirement planning software company formerly known as NewRetirement, raised the price of its PlannerPlus subscription from $144 to $168 a year for new customers. The company announced the change on Oct. 1. Existing subscribers keep their old price for now, the company said. The same pricing page lists a Basic tier at no charge and a $3,200 flat-fee retirement plan checkup with a certified financial planner.
That one page holds the two prices now reshaping the retirement planning business. The software is cheap or free. The human costs a fixed sum. Several companies, from venture-backed Boldin to a one-person site, sell some version of that pair. The percentage-of-assets fee remains the industry’s main charge. The alternatives are growing beside it.
What the free tier includes
Boldin’s Basic tier covers a personalized plan, “what if” scenarios and 100-plus inputs, per its pricing page, plus up to five questions a day to its AI assistant, per its help center. Monte Carlo analysis, tax projections and a Roth conversion explorer sit in the $168 PlannerPlus tier. That subscription rose from $120 to $144 in July 2025, according to comments on a White Coat Investor review.
ProjectionLab draws the line in a different place. Its Basic plan is listed at $0 a year and includes Monte Carlo simulations plus historical backtesting. Premium costs $129 a year. Pro, built for advisers, costs $549. The company’s changelog said on Oct. 13, 2025, that tax estimation was now free, though its pricing page lists Tax Estimation among Premium features. The Basic plan does not save data between sessions, Rob Berger wrote in a July 2026 review. ProjectionLab’s pricing page does not state that restriction.
firenum.com, a smaller independent site, has no paid tier. Its revenue page states there are “no paywalls, no premium tiers, no locked features.” A user enters income, spending and savings, then sees a retirement date checked three ways: average returns, 500 simulated markets, and every start year since 1872 in Shiller S&P 500 data. Six stress tests cover a crash, lower returns, income loss, a spending spike, high inflation and retiring earlier or later. The planner computes federal, state and payroll tax for all 50 states plus the District of Columbia. There is no account. The site’s FAQ says everything entered “stays in your browser’s localStorage” and adds, “The site does use analytics.”
Free calculators sit beside all three. FI Calc is donation-supported. cFIREsim lists no pricing. Engaging Data states that inputs to its calculator never leave the browser. FIREproof, described on its homepage as “from the creator of cFIREsim.com,” is freemium: one saved simulation at no charge, with Monte Carlo, Roth conversions and ACA subsidy optimization in a $10-a-month Pro plan.
Pralana moved the other way. The Excel-based planner put Pralana Gold on an annual subscription on Oct. 1, 2026, at $129 the first year and $99 on renewal, which it called its first price rise in over a decade. Its free Bronze tier “will be discontinued soon,” per the purchase page.
The incumbents pair free planning with a paid product. Empower calls its dashboard free. Its advisory service charges from 0.89% of assets, with a minimum listed as $100,000 on one page and $250,000 on another. Origin charges $99 a year for its app and $119 for a one-off session with a CFP professional.
The adviser comes attached
Boldin Advisors, a wholly owned subsidiary of the software company, lists a Retirement Plan Checkup at a $3,200 flat fee and ongoing advice from $1,200 a year on its adviser page. The checkup includes a 90-minute call with a CFP professional and a written Plan of Action, per Boldin’s engagement page. The firm announced SEC registration in June 2025. Its Form CRS lists no account minimum. Its Form ADV states it manages no assets. The firm’s SEC disclosures state it is financially incentivized to recommend the boldin.com software.
ProjectionLab sells the relationship from the adviser’s side. Its $549 Pro tier buys 10 client seats and a listing in an Advisor Directory that held 27 entries on Oct. 21. The directory page states ProjectionLab “does not endorse, verify, or guarantee any listed information or professional.”
firenum’s directory lists six fee-only advisers, two coaches and two financial therapists, with one person appearing in both of the last two groups. The site says each was reviewed before listing and that “no one pays to be listed.” A separate plan-review page prices a $500 one-hour consult and a $3,000 written plan from a fee-only adviser. The adviser pays the site a 20% referral fee, the page states: $100 of a consult, $600 of a plan. Sessions are for U.S. residents outside New York. As of Oct. 21 the page did not yet name the adviser.
Marketplaces sell the hour on its own. Nectarine, created in 2023 according to a Marriage Kids and Money review, advertises advice-only sessions at $225 to $500 an hour and one-time plans at $2,800 to $6,500. It says it accepted fewer than 10% of adviser applicants. AdviceOnly, a San Diego RIA, lists planners with fees such as “From $200/hr.” Its founder, Steven Fox, told Financial Planning in March 2025: “It’s just separating investment management from financial advice, which is what a lot of consumers want in the first place.” Fox is also one of the six advisers in the directory described above.
The flat-fee membership firms price above that band. Facet lists $2,600 to $8,700 a year. Range charges $3,950 to $12,500 and bundles an AI adviser called Rai with a human planning team.
Payment data shows the model spreading. AdvicePay, which processes planning fees for advisers, reported in March 2026 that 85.6% of its 2025 invoices were subscriptions. The average monthly fee was $291. “Fee-for-service planning has moved from ‘alternative’ to operational standard,” said Alan Moore, the company’s co-founder and CEO. Cerulli projected 77.6% of advisers would be fee-based by 2026 and found 21% charge a direct fee for a plan, per InvestmentNews. The percentage fee still dominates. Kitces Research data from 2024, published in June 2025, shows 86% of advisory firms rely on asset-based fees as their primary charge, with a median of 1% on a $1 million client.
Three shifts in the background
Mint closed. Intuit Credit Karma announced on Oct. 31, 2023, that the budgeting app “is going away.” The shutdown date moved from Jan. 1 to March 23, 2024, per Clark.com, which reported that users could move linked accounts, balances and net worth history to Credit Karma and that it remained to be seen how other Mint features would carry over.
Data sharing drew scrutiny. Incogni tested 20 popular Android budgeting apps in July 2023 and found 12 shared at least some user data with third parties. One in four shared financial information. A Consumer Reports evaluation of 10 mobile banking apps, conducted in 2023 and published in 2024, found that “almost all banking apps share data beyond what is necessary to provide the service, including with marketing partners and for joint marketing purposes.” Two of the tools above, Engaging Data’s calculator and firenum, state that numbers stay in the browser.
AI arrived. Boldin launched its AI assistant in January 2026 at no extra charge. TD’s 2026 AI Insights Report, a survey of 2,504 adults, found 55% use AI to help manage their finances, up from 10% a year earlier. Only 18% said they would trust AI to make financial recommendations on its own. Gallup reported in August 2026 that 79% of Americans have at least some confidence in financial advisers. For AI tools the figure was no more than three in 10.
Where the paid tier still earns its fee
Memory and support come first. ProjectionLab’s $0 plan loses the plan between sessions, per Berger’s review. Boldin’s paid tier holds the document vault, live classes and multiple scenarios.
Accuracy is an older problem. A 2016 study by Taft Dorman, Barry Mulholland, Qianwen Bi and Harold Evensky ran one test couple through 36 retirement planning tools available at no or modest cost. Most failed to warn the couple that their plan was too risky, according to a CXO Advisory summary, which put the count at 25 of 36. The summary blamed inconsistent inputs and default settings, such that “most generate misleading retirement expectations.” The study predates several tools in this article, including firenum and ProjectionLab.
Vendors close. Playbook, a subscription planning app with an in-house adviser, announced on Oct. 1, 2024, that it was winding down. Its adviser arm stopped giving advice “effective immediately.” Schwab disclosed in December 2025 SEC filings that it would shut Intelligent Portfolios Premium, its $30-a-month plan with CFP access, in the first quarter of 2026, InvestmentNews reported. Both were paid products.
Referral money is the last line to read. firenum’s revenue page states its only revenue model is affiliate commissions and that it had “zero active affiliate partnerships” in October 2026. The FTC’s Endorsement Guides, revised in 2023, say a material connection, including payment, that a significant minority of consumers would not expect must be disclosed clearly and conspicuously. ProjectionLab’s paid-only directory, the 20% fee on the plan-review page and Boldin Advisors’ incentive to recommend its parent’s software are each printed on the companies’ own pages or filings.
What it means for someone choosing
Charles Schwab’s 2025 Modern Wealth Survey found 31% of Americans have documented their goals in a formal plan. A third have no plan of any kind. Cerulli reported in February 2026 that 63% of affluent investors have used online tools to understand their finances. Among those who call online goal-tracking tools essential, 36% prefer online-only advice and 46% would rather have a human adviser in the relationship.
What the human is worth is a contested number. Vanguard’s Advisor’s Alpha brief puts the potential value at “about 3%” net of taxes and fees, with 150 basis points from behavioral coaching. The same brief says the figure is “not added over a specific time frame” and varies each year. Vanguard sells advice. DALBAR measured the average equity investor 848 basis points behind the S&P 500 in 2024, the second-largest gap of the decade. In 2025 the gap narrowed to 72 basis points, the lowest since 2012. Morningstar’s 2012 “Gamma” paper, reprinted by Retirement Income Journal, estimated five planning decisions yield 29% more retirement income, equivalent to a 1.82% higher annual return. A backtest published by firenum claims a 40-year retirement succeeds 86.2% of the time when the investor stays invested and 46.3% when they panic. That is the site’s own number, built on a modeled 1.5% annual behavior drag. The same page concludes a 1%-of-assets fee claws back most of the value.
Christine Benz of Morningstar argued for paying a planner for one decision, buying an annuity, on the White Coat Investor podcast in January 2026. “Even if you have to pay that hourly planner for a small piece of his or her time, to me, getting some quarterbacking on that decision-making can be money well spent,” she said. “So, don’t cheap out and go strictly the DIY route.”
The arithmetic for a reader now runs like this. A projection with Monte Carlo and a historical backtest costs $0 on at least three of the sites above, and ProjectionLab’s free plan does not keep the plan between sessions. Tax projections and a Roth explorer cost $168 a year at Boldin. A one-off human review costs $3,200 at Boldin’s adviser firm, and firenum’s plan-review page lists a $500 one-hour consult with an adviser it does not yet name. An hour at Nectarine costs $225 to $500, and AdviceOnly lists planners from $200 an hour. A 1% fee on a $1 million portfolio costs $10,000 every year. What the cheaper route gives up is saved data on some tiers, a help desk, and any certainty the vendor outlasts the plan. What it keeps is the choice of when, and whether, to pay a person.






















