Wednesday, July 2, 2025
Distribution: (800) 510 0384
Washington DC
New York
Toronto
Press ID  
  • Login
The Hudson Weekly
  • Financial
  • Blockchain
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Cybersecurity
No Result
View All Result
  • Financial
  • Blockchain
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Cybersecurity
No Result
View All Result
The Hudson Weekly
No Result
View All Result

Hard Times at Starboard: The King of Activist Hedge Funds Hits a Rough Patch

Craig Richer by Craig Richer
May 14, 2022
in Financial
A A
Hard Times at Starboard: The King of Activist Hedge Funds Hits a Rough Patch

Hard Times at Starboard: The King of Activist Hedge Funds Hits a Rough Patch

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Is the tide turning for activist hedge funds? Judging from one of the largest player’s recent woes, the answer may be yes.

Only a few years ago such funds, which take large positions in public traded companies and then aggressively call for major changes to unlock value, were being touted as a panacea for underperforming companies. In 2015, The Economist called them “Capitalism’s Unlikely Heroes.”

HudsonNewsroom

Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know

From Strategy to Execution: The Full Spectrum of White Label Digital Marketing

From Investopedia to eCheckcasinos.ca – Exploring the World of Responsible Betting: An Interview With Lucy Adegbe

But the bloom may be off the rose. Activist funds are facing more resistance from stakeholders who may be skeptical that proposed “reforms” are really in their interest. Most notably, leading activist hedge fund Starboard Value, which boasts more than $7 billion in assets and has muscled its way into more board of directors seats of publicly traded companies than any of its peers, has found itself in an unaccustomed place: on the losing side of a high-profile proxy battles – not once, but twice.

In March 2022, shareholders of specialty chemicals maker Huntsman Corp. declined to elect any of Starboard’s five nominees to board seats, opting to elect all 10 candidates endorsed by Huntsman’s current management team. And in September 2021, software company Box Inc. easily defeated Starboard’s slate of board candidates, ending the hedge fund’s bid to assume control of the company.

Huntsman was able to push back against Starboard’s arguments by pointing to impressive revenue, earnings and margin growth and management promises to enhance shareholder value through share repurchases. Box also posted solid earnings shortly before the shareholder vote, but it probably didn’t go unnoticed by shareholders that Starboard’s record of influencing or running software companies after assuming board seats has been anything but impressive.

Over the past five years, Starboard has assumed board seats on four software companies: Comscore, Symantec, Commvault and eHealth. The average return for the four stocks since Starboard’s involvement is -37.8%; the longest holding, Comscore, has lost 94% of its value since Starboard began lending its expertise in July 2017.

It’s a sharp contrast to Starboard’s most famous success story. The activist hedge fund took over Darden Restaurants, owner of the Olive Garden chain, by winning all seats on its board in October 2014. The sweeping shareholder coup was preceded by a now-legendary 294-page presentation by Starboard that called, in granular detail, for such changes as changing the number and frequency of breadsticks served in the Italian restaurants. In the years after Starboard’s power play, Darden performed significantly better, boosting the hedge fund’s reputation. Darden stock is up nearly 200% under Starboard’s management.

It could be that the intricacies of the software business could be more complicated than counting breadsticks. Starboard essentially took over security software company Symantec (now Norton LifeLock) in November 2018, and Starboard Managing Member and Head of Research Peter Feld continues to sit on its board. Yet after a series of asset sales and restructurings, Norton stock is almost flat since then – a period during which the broad stock market is up nearly 50%, even including this year’s correction.

A High Stakes Game

The playbook for Starboard is fairly standard: the hedge fund declares a stake in a company in an SEC filing, then quickly moves to force change – often with a letter or presentation outlining its diagnosis of the company’s supposed underperformance. In January 2022, for example, Starboard declared a 7.3% stake in aerospace and defense tech giant Mercury Systems. At the same time, it demanded the company drop its shareholders’ rights plan and pushed for greater corporate control. The next step, if history is any guide: Starboard will nominate its own slate of nominees for Mercury Systems’ board and present detailed proposals promising impressive returns if Starboard gains control.

But observers are starting to question who benefits from these attacks: shareholders, or the activist hedge fund?

While the push for profits from an activist shareholder may sound like a win-win situation for companies and their staff, this often means prioritizing short-term wins over longer-term strategies for business success. The self-serving approach taken by Starboard and other activists has led to less than stellar track records of creating flourishing businesses. The Harvard Business Review reported that once activist hedge funds take over a company, “activists reduce employee headcount by an average of 12%, while R&D gets cut by more than half.”

Experts who specialize in helping companies fight hedge funds like Starboard Value warn that activist investors risk losing everything when they remove key experienced directors or upend long-term COVID recovery strategies. Overreaching for a win in the post-pandemic crisis, says Sabastian Niles of Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to CNCBC, will ultimately mean Starboard (and others like it) will be remembered as “failing to meet the moment.”

Indeed, history may look back at this moment as a turning point when shareholders woke up to the failure of activist hedge funds to keep their promises and, like consumers dealing with spam marketing, hit “unsubscribe.”

Craig Richer

Craig Richer

Newsroom Editor

More from HW Newsdesk

Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know
Financial

Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know

July 1, 2025
From Strategy to Execution: The Full Spectrum of White Label Digital Marketing
Financial

From Strategy to Execution: The Full Spectrum of White Label Digital Marketing

June 27, 2025
From Investopedia to eCheckcasinos.ca – Exploring the World of Responsible Betting: An Interview with Lucy Adegbe
Financial

From Investopedia to eCheckcasinos.ca – Exploring the World of Responsible Betting: An Interview With Lucy Adegbe

June 27, 2025

HW Newsroom

Freddy Will
Entertainment

Revival & Resilience: The Unstoppable Freddy Will

by Dennis Keller
July 1, 2025

In an era where digital music and literary distribution intersect with relentless cyber threats, Grammy-nominated artist and author Freddy Will...

Finding Your Match: Selecting the Ideal Casino Game

Is Luck or Logic Winning More in Poker Now?

July 1, 2025
Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know

Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know

July 1, 2025
Reasons Why You Need a High-Quality Mouse Pad

Reasons Why You Need a High-Quality Mouse Pad

July 1, 2025
Why Ignoring HVAC Maintenance Can Cost You More in the Long Run

Why Ignoring HVAC Maintenance Can Cost You More in the Long Run

July 1, 2025
Tips to Buy Cylinder Carts: What You Need to Know

Tips to Buy Cylinder Carts: What You Need to Know

July 1, 2025
Benefits of Boat and RV Services in Austin

Benefits of Boat and RV Services in Austin

July 1, 2025
Why These Jewish Symbols Still Matter Today

Why These Jewish Symbols Still Matter Today

July 1, 2025
What Jewish Symbols Really Mean: From Ancient Art to Modern Judaica

What Jewish Symbols Really Mean: From Ancient Art to Modern Judaica

July 1, 2025
A Vivid Window Into the Past, A Beacon of Hope for the Future

A Vivid Window Into the Past, A Beacon of Hope for the Future

June 30, 2025
Preventative Botox®: The Strategy for Keeping Skin Smooth Before Wrinkles Set In

Preventative Botox®: The Strategy for Keeping Skin Smooth Before Wrinkles Set In

June 27, 2025
9 Most Popular Gaming Genres

4 Tips for Safe Online Gaming

June 27, 2025
No Result
View All Result

Headlines

The Dirtiest Places in Your Home — And You’re Probably Ignoring Them

Yevhen Kasyanenko on Smart Contracts: How Blockchain Technology Works in Simple Terms

Ghana’s Best Licensed Betting Platforms – Safe & Legal Bookmakers

Revival & Resilience: The Unstoppable Freddy Will

Is Luck or Logic Winning More in Poker Now?

Understanding Caregiver Insurance: What You Need to Know

Trending

Key Benefits of Working With a Custom Application Development
Technology

Key Benefits of Working With a Custom Application Development

by Ryan Offman
July 1, 2025

Last month, I spoke with Sarah, who runs a mid-sized logistics company. She'd been struggling with her...

Beyond the Headlines: What’s Driving Clinical Trials in Eastern Europe?

Beyond the Headlines: What’s Driving Clinical Trials in Eastern Europe?

July 1, 2025
The Dirtiest Places in Your Home — And You’re Probably Ignoring Them

The Dirtiest Places in Your Home — And You’re Probably Ignoring Them

July 1, 2025
Yevhen Kasyanenko on Smart Contracts: How Blockchain Technology Works in Simple Terms

Yevhen Kasyanenko on Smart Contracts: How Blockchain Technology Works in Simple Terms

July 1, 2025
Where Gamblers Go When They Want More: Exploring Unconventional Casino Choices

Ghana’s Best Licensed Betting Platforms – Safe & Legal Bookmakers

July 1, 2025
  • Kia America представляет цены и захватывающие обновления для Sorento 2025 (ICE)

https://madisongraph.com/kia-america-unveils-pricing-and-exciting-updates-for-2025-sorento-ice/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • Kia Recognized as One of TIME Magazine’s “World’s Most Sustainable Companies of 2024”

https://madisongraph.com/kia-recognized-as-one-of-time-magazines-worlds-most-sustainable-companies-of-2024/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • VinFast Auto Establishes Dealer Advisory Board to Enhance Customer Experience

https://madisongraph.com/vinfast-auto-establishes-dealer-advisory-board-to-enhance-customer-experience/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • Medicare Announces Expansion of Coverage for Microprocessor-Controlled Knees for Lower Mobility Users

https://lincolncitizen.com/medicare-announces-expansion-of-coverage-for-microprocessor-controlled-knees-for-lower-mobility-users/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • GA-ASI Successfully Tests PT6 Engine on MQ-9B SkyGuardian Aircraft

https://lincolncitizen.com/ga-asi-successfully-tests-pt6-engine-on-mq-9b-skyguardian-aircraft/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • U.S. Leading Economic Index Declines by 0.2% in June 2024, Coincident Index Rises by 0.3%

https://fairmontpost.com/u-s-leading-economic-index-declines-by-0-2-in-june-2024-coincident-index-rises-by-0-3/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • USTDA Director Travels to Bulgaria and Romania to Promote Clean, Secure Energy

https://belmontstar.com/ustda-director-travels-to-bulgaria-and-romania-to-promote-clean-secure-energy/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost
  • Police Recommend a Hidden Camera Detector Device to Protect Privacy

https://marketsherald.com/police-recommend-a-hidden-camera-detector-device-to-protect-privacy/

#nyc #losangeles #chicago #houston #phoenix #philadelphia #sandiego #dallas #sanfrancisco #seattle #denver #washingtondc #boston #detroit #vancouver #toronto #publicrelations #marketingagency #earnedmedia #editorial #marketing #guestpost #guestposting #sponsored #sponsoredpost

© 2025 The Hudson Weekly. Published by The Ritz Herald. Editions: Markets Herald • Lincoln Citizen • Madison Graph • Belmont Star • Fairmont Post

Address: 1177 6th Avenue, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10036. Removals: pr@hudsonweekly.com. Phone: (718) 313-5252. M-F: 9AM-5PM. Privacy Policy

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Financial
  • Blockchain
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Arts
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Cybersecurity

© 2025. The Hudson Weekly